[CrackMonkey] Lindsey Graham
Rick Moen
rick at linuxmafia.com
Wed Feb 23 14:00:11 PST 2000
Quoting Mike Goldman (whig at debian.org):
> Seth David Schoen wrote:
>
>> I think my present position is close to "Voting is wrong, but it does not
>> in itself constitute consent".
>
> Consent for the PROCESS, certainly. Look, nobody is FORCING people to
> vote. So if you do it, you have willingly accepted the rules.
The word "so", in the above, seems to imply causation. Yet, it's
non-obvious how your conclusion follows from your premises.
You may have intended to express your ending sentence as a personal
opinion, but it's framed in the form of a logical deduction.
> It's like, when someone offers you a deal, and you accept the
> benefits, you acquire the obligation.
Supplementing that unsupported assertion with an analogy doesn't help
much.
> You CAN complain, no matter what, but whether you have proper STANDING to
> complain depends again on what you are complaining about.
"Standing" is an undefined term, in this context. (It has a defined
meaning in legal contexts.)
--
Cheers, The cynics among us might say: "We laugh,
Rick Moen monkeyboys -- Linux IS the mainstream UNIX now!
rick (at) linuxmafia.com MuaHaHaHa!" but that would be rude. -- Jim Dennis
More information about the Crackmonkey
mailing list